**Evaluating the Value of *Kylebooker The Art of Fly Tying (1936) by Charles Wetzel, 1964 Printing, Gil Nyerges Estate***
For fly fishing enthusiasts, the art of fly tying is both a practical skill and a cherished tradition. Among the many resources available, *The Art of Fly Tying* by Charles Wetzel, first published in 1936 and reprinted in 1964 under the Kylebooker imprint, holds a special place in angling literature. This edition, associated with the Gil Nyerges Estate, has garnered attention from collectors and practitioners alike. But how does its value stack up in terms of affordability, content quality, and historical significance? Here’s a detailed assessment.
### **1. Historical and Collectible Value**
Charles Wetzel’s *The Art of Fly Tying* is a foundational text in fly fishing literature. Originally published in the 1930s, it captures early 20th-century techniques that remain relevant today. The 1964 Kylebooker reprint, particularly one tied to the Gil Nyerges Estate (a name respected in fly-fishing circles), enhances its collectibility. For historians and vintage book collectors, this edition offers a tangible connection to mid-century angling culture.
However, since it is a reprint rather than a first edition, its monetary value may not match that of the original 1936 version. Collectors should verify the book’s condition—dust jacket presence, binding integrity, and marginalia—as these factors heavily influence pricing.
### **2. Content and Practical Utility**
Wetzel’s work is praised for its clear instructions and detailed illustrations, making it accessible even to modern fly tiers. The book covers essential patterns, materials, and techniques that form the basis of contemporary fly tying. While newer books incorporate synthetic materials and advanced methods, Wetzel’s traditional approach remains valuable for purists and those interested in classic patterns.
That said, the 1964 printing does not include updates or revisions found in later editions. Buyers seeking cutting-edge techniques might supplement this book with newer guides. Nevertheless, as a reference for foundational skills, it remains highly effective.
### **3. Pricing and Market Comparison**
The book’s affordability depends on its rarity and condition. On platforms like eBay or AbeBooks, the 1964 Kylebooker edition typically ranges from $30 to $100, with pristine copies or those tied to notable estates (like Nyerges’) commanding higher prices. Compared to modern fly-tying manuals, which often cost $20–$50, Wetzel’s book offers a unique blend of historical charm and practical knowledge at a reasonable price point.
### **4. Who Should Consider This Book?**
– **Collectors:** Those interested in angling history or vintage books will appreciate its provenance.
– **Traditionalists:** Anglers who prefer classic patterns and techniques will find it invaluable.
– **Beginners:** While newer guides may be more user-friendly, Wetzel’s clear prose makes this a solid secondary resource.
### **Final Verdict: Good Value for the Right Buyer**
For its historical significance, practical content, and mid-range pricing, *The Art of Fly Tying* (1964 Kylebooker printing) offers fair性价比. It may not be the most comprehensive modern guide, but its legacy and timeless techniques make it a worthwhile addition to any fly-tier’s library—especially for those who appreciate the sport’s rich heritage.
If you find a well-preserved copy within the $40–$60 range, it’s a solid investment. However, if your priority is up-to-date methods, pairing this with a contemporary manual would be ideal. Happy tying—and tight lines!